This blog is now closed

Evaluation 4 - Audience feedback

What have you learnt from your audience feedback?


For my audience feedback I found it would be most beneficial to plan my feedback in terms using a range of ways to collect it and focusing on my target audience.


Interviews

My first form of collecting this feedback was through the process of interviews. When planning what kind of interview I would use I looked at how I wanted use the feedback in terms of creating an idea of how successful my production is. In order to discover if my video

1) Appeals to the desired target audience
2) Fits the codes and conventions of its intended Genre
3) Presents its themes and concepts
4) Has an understandable narrative
5) How well the Digipak accompanies the video

These are the four main points I planned to achieve with my video and so I planned to base my questions around these so therefore I decided I would ask my volunteers the same planned questions and see how they respond.

My questions...

• Do you think this video fits the indie/dance/alternative genre? why?
• Who do you think this video is aimed at in terms of target audience?
• Do you understand the narrative of the video? What are your interpretations of the narrative?
• What themes and concepts do the think are portrayed in this video?
• Do you find the Digipak suited the video and its genre?
• Do you think both the video and Digipak could be a real media product?
• Do you have any additional comments?

I chose my participants in terms of age therefore my video is aimed at more teenagers but also chose to interview one older participant to compare answers. 

These are my interviews and what I learnt from their feedback

Francines responses are innovative and helpful. From this interview I learnt that

• Our themes and concepts are strong
• Our editing is effective and different
• Our suitability for our genre is strong
• Our video has a profesional finish

The responses from Natasha were very similar and I found that again our concepts were strong. What i learnt from this interview is that

• Our narrative isn't clear
• Our video is different and 'edgy'

Georgias responses are very similar and in some way a combination of the two above.



Overall what I learnt from these interviews are...

• What we could have improved is our narrative
• What we achieved well is the quality of our video and out concept.

Questionnaires 

This is a questionnaire that I created that I emailed to 20 people who I considered to be part of my target audience.

I decided that I wanted to gain some numerical feedback that I could input in to graphs therefore I chose to use the yes/no answer option. This allowed me to put the answers for each question in to a graph. I structured the questions so that an answer of yes meant success in achieving what the answer suggests and no meant we did not in the participants opinion.

These are my results of from the 20 participants that answered the questions

The response for this question is mostly positive as results show 85% of people said they enjoyed the video or found it entertaining. From this I have learnt that we were successful in make the video appealing in terms of drawing an audience in. 

Again this response is mostly positive meaning the Digipak worked well and consistently with the video to effectively create a good media package. 

This is a mainly positive response however it is not as successful as the last results. 40% of people felt the video did NOT suit the song. When creating our production song choice became an issue in terms of suiting the ideas and footage we had meaning we had to change our original song so pick a better suited one. What I learnt from this is that we may have been more successful if we had found a song we really wanted to work with then based our ideas around that rather than the other way around. 

Again this result isn't as impressive as it means almost have of the participants did NOT find that control and freedom came across as a main theme in our video. This could be because we focused so much on making youth and identity a theme that these concepts became to overshadowed. One thing I have learnt from this is to maybe not make the concepts and themes to complicated and stick to a solid few. 

Question 5 showed excellent results with 100% of the participants finding the concept and themes of youth and youth culture clear in the video. This links back to my last comment that we focused greatly on this idea.

This is again a positive result as most people found the theme of identity noticeable in our video. This is something that we made very obvious therefore it was a part of the video that was very visual for example the masks. One thing this has shown me is that possible the most visually striking parts of a production are the most identifiable ones.

This question related to the profitability of our products and whether people would purchase it. It is fairly successful but 30% of people claimed that they would not buy it. However this could be down to the age of downloads and the fact there is no long a necessity to buy music if you wish to listen to it.

The last question referred to how professional and real our media products seemed. The results are mostly positive which shows the minor detail we included did make a difference to the finished result.

Audience theory applied to my results

Stuart hall suggested different readings defined by audiences responses. Of the different readings the one that best applies to my results of my questionnaire would be 

NEGOTIATED READINGS

This means the audience Audiences partially except but are not completely persuaded and are open to other views

I have based this result on the fact for question four , five and six of my questionnaire the responses although mostly positive their were very mixed particularly due to question 4 meaning the understanding wasn't entirely adopted. 

Audience feedback via social networking sites

The rise is social networks has not only proved key for advertising but also for audience research and feedback. Networking sites such as Twitter and Facebook have encouraged the expression of opinion over the last few years and this is a prime opportunity for record companies and artist to gain effective feedback. 

I decided to use twitter to gain feedback on the finished video to product by tweeting the link and asking for comments.

By doing this people 'mentioned' the band and responded with their comments

What I learnt from this...

This feedback was positive and although its an effective way of gaining comments people the reply tend to be a person that is 'following' you which often tends to be a fan. This can create a bias result as the comments are more likely to be positive. However I did gain from this small amount of feedback that we were successful in terms of our target audience as viewing the profiles of the respondents showed they were apparently part the age range and character we aimed to appeal to. 

Treatment/pitch

At the start of our coursework we pitched our ideas for our video to the rest of our class. This was effective audience feedback because

• It was physical interaction with our audience and so there was more space for discussion and comments.
• It created a general idea of how people would respond to the video
• It was a visual presentation instead of a questionnaire etc which helped portray our ideas more effectively 

media on Prezi

Evaluation 3 - Media technology

Considering this evaluation question was linked to media technology we decided to be creative and used quicktime to film this internally on the mac

Evaluation question 2 - DIgipak

How effective is the combination of your music video and your digipak?


When creating my Digipak I aimed to create a synergy between my music video and the Digipak itself. I wanted to create the consistency that most artists have within their media products that help with the branding and identity of their music.

Stills from the video 


One way in which I create a continuity between my digipak and video is by using stills as images from footage included in the video itself. 



These images are from the scenic footage shown in the video below that we shot to include in our video. The effect of this is that it creates a familiarity to the audience as when they see these images they have already been introduced to them and clips of this style in the video. 


The urban setting is an important part of our music video and so by keeping it consistent and including it in the Digipak ensures the tone and urban feel of the music doesn't fade away. 








The idea of keeping significant images continuous and re using them to create a familiarity is an idea o also used when creating my magazine advert.
The image I used on my album cover below I found to be my favorite and from the audience research I did while creating my Magazine advert I found it was effective to use the same image within two different types of media product.






However I did make some changes to the image in order to ensure the two parts of my digipak didnt look to similar. Using photo shop I reduced the saturation on the image for the magazine advert which removed the colour and created an effective black and white photo.

Colour Grading


I spent a lot of time working on the images I decided to use for my digipak in order to give them they impression they could be images that would fit perfectly in to our music video.

As you can see the pictures have the same effect on them throughout the digipak. This effect is called mikhjifh and the software I used to create this is called Instagram. Instrgram is an 'app' which is a new technology which allows you to add software and programs to a mobile phone or android. Within this app i was able to try a range of different effects on the images and see which one suits best.


This is a print screen from the Instagram app.




This is my album  cover and magazine advert among various still shots from my music video. As you can see I have matched the the tones of pink and red are highlighted and the use of colour is made to be sharp yet muted in to shades of black and grey.

Concept and themes

The most significant and effective way in which I kept an effective synergy between my video and digipak is by continuing the ideas of my concepts and themes. The themes of Youth, Identity and Youth culture in the media is something we have tried to portray and play with throughout our video and I have therefore used this to create my Digipak. 

• On  my album cover the image I have used is representative of the rebellious behavior attached to youth as the arm is heavily tattooed. By using this image I have presented the theme of youth culture but by showing in a positive light as the tattooed arm in the position it is place with the shadowed behind looks very artists and creative which we want to promote as characters of youth rather than some of the stereotypes such as violence.
• I have used my track titles and the style in which they are presented to again make reference to the portrayal and image of youth in the media. The way in which I have done this is by making them appear as though they are cut out of a newspaper. A newspaper is not something usually attached to the image of youth as being something they would read and appreciate. It is however attached the way in which they are demonized so by using this style to imply the words have come from a newspaper plays on that idea. It also is suggestive of demolishing the newspaper and rearranging the words of the newspaper to fit the youth.  

• On my front cover I have used an old photo from my facebook of a crowd at a party. This links to the theme and concept in our video of Youth culture, freedom and generally having fun which is the image want to portray of youth. We have also included scenes in our video that are suggestive of parties so it continues the narrative of the girl having fun. 
• I have also again used the newspaper cut out style text.
• The parental advisory sticker  is supposed to be kind of a pun as freedom and youth are our themes.

Evaluation Question 1 - Forms and conventions of real media products

Copy of Evaluation Question One on Prezi


For this evaluation question we made a Prezi. 

Our twitter teaser post

Follow the idea from Justin Bieber idea we decided to create a teaser and post tweets leading up to its release.

This is a print screen of the post in which we released out teaser.

Justin bieber teasers

Justin Bieber is an artist that has had incredible success in the past year. One thing he is known for is amount of attention he has gained on twitter.

Prior to his new single release he used twitter to post video teaser for the up and coming video for his new single 'boyfriend'. This idea is effective as it creates a kind of hysteria and build up to the final video.